Change to Employment Agreement Extends Limitation Period

The standard limitation period for claims in Ontario is two years. If an individual or business is considering a lawsuit they are always well advised to consult a Lawyer as early as possible to determine when the two year limitation period begins and when it ends.

The recent Ontario Court of Appeal case, Ali v. O-Two Medical Technologies Inc. 2013 ONCA 733, shows the difficulty of determining a limitation period in certain employment disputes. In this case the Plaintiff worked on commission to sell medical devices in Iraq for his employer. Shortly after one such significant sale in December 2006 the employer notified the Plaintiff that it was unilaterally changing his commission structure. The Plaintiff continued working for his employer but informed it that he expected the original and higher commission to be paid. After the sale was completed the employer paid the Plaintiff the reduced commission in November 2007. Unhappy with the lower commission, the Plaintiff eventually started a court action in September 2009, well over two years from the date that he was first informed of the new commission structure.

The employer argued that by the time the Plaintiff commenced his court action over two years had passed since he was informed of the changes to his contract and it was too late to bring the dispute to court. However, in December 2013 the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that this was not the case and decided that the two year limitation period did not start until the Plaintiff actually received the reduced commission in November 2007. The Plaintiff's court action was allowed to proceed.

Whenever an employer tries to modify an existing contract by reducing an employee’s compensation it creates the possibility of a legal action. The case of Ali v. O-Two Medical Technologies Inc. is an interesting example of when these contractual changes also increase the limitation period in which an employee can commence a claim in court.

‍Based in Kanata, the law firm of Allan Snelling LLP provides employment law advice to both employees and employers throughout Ottawa and the surrounding area.

Frequently Asked Questions

Fired without Cause - Should you take the offer?

I was fired without cause. My employer has given me an offer. Should I take it?

Answer: Employers aren’t handcuffed to their employees. If they act in accordance with their statutory and common law obligations, employers are free to part ways with employees without cause. Typically, the employer is obliged to provide statutory or common law reasonable notice or payment in lieu of notice. Costs, benefits, risks and reward of bringing legal action, should all be considered, prior to starting a claim.

Needlessly pursuing litigation could potentially prejudice the employee. You could delay the settlement and run the risk of losing a fair offer. You may find another job in the weeks following termination. If this happens, then the employer’s settlement may be subject to mitigation which means that they are credited the wages you obtain from that new job. You may also pay more in legal fees then the additional notice you should have received.

There are cases where employees are grossly underpaid when it comes to severance, so I do advocate that everyone who faces termination seek counsel to go over any severance offer. Do not sign it blindly. Speak to a Lawyer and make sure the offer is fair. Employers will often expect and, if prudent, will insist that their past employees reach out to counsel when deciding to sign a severance offer. You should do so as soon as possible after receiving the offer.

Resources:

Need an Employment Lawyer? Reach out today. You may be eligible for a FREE no obligation consultation.

Are paid and unpaid internships illegal in Ontario?

I own a small events and promotions business. Every so often I get emails from students asking if they could volunteer to learn about the business. I’ve never hired a student because they’re inexperienced but I’m considering hiring one as an intern this summer. I don’t have the budget for a full time employee but I would be willing to pay them a modest stipend. I’ve heard both paid and unpaid internships are illegal in Ontario. Is this true?

In Ontario, the rules around internships are strict and in recent years some employers have been required to change their internship programs as a result. If someone is receiving on the job training from a business they are considered to be an employee of the business under Ontario law. As an employee they are entitled to a minimum wage under the Employment Standards Act so paying them a stipend that does not meet the minimum wage is against the law.

There are two exceptions to this general rule which recognize the educational value of internships. The first is internship programs approved by a college or university which are permitted.

The second exception is internships that meet criteria set by the Ministry of Labour. These requirements include that the intern is receiving valuable training, is not taking someone else’s job, and has not been promised a job after their training. The most important feature is the educational component: the primary purpose of internships is to teach valuable skills, not to provide cheap labour to businesses.

The safest way to ensure compliance with the law is to have an internship approved as part of a college or university program. Alternatively, you should design the internship ahead of time to focus it around training and skills development.

Short-Term Disability Insurance: What should you do when a claim is denied?

I have been off work since May 2016 and have been trying to obtain short-term disability insurance since then. My doctor has provided me with three sick notes since then and at our last appointment she told me not to work. However, my application for short-term disability insurance has been denied. I’ve given the disability insurer the notes from my doctor and I’ve gone through the appeal process but have been denied again. My employer is now asking when I will return and I’ve booked an appointment with my doctor to see what she thinks. What should I do?

‍It is not uncommon for disability insurers to deny an initial application for short-term disability benefits. Often the reason cited for the denial is a lack of medical evidence of a disability. If the only documentation you have provided to the insurer are sick notes from your doctor it is usually of assistance to obtain further medical records from your doctor including something documenting your diagnosis. Often, after receiving such additional documentation an insurer will approve an application for disability benefits. If you continue to be denied benefits, it is likely time to consult with legal counsel. Also short-term disability benefits typically end within 6 months even if you are approved. Ensure you know when these benefits end and decide with your doctor whether you should be applying for long-term disability benefits if they are available to you.

With respect to returning to work you are entitled to rely on your doctor’s advice. If your doctor tells you not to work this should be documented in a doctor’s note and provided to your employer. Forcing you to return to work when your doctor says you’re sick is in breach of human rights legislation and it’s unlikely that your employer will insist on your return to work in the face of your doctor’s advice.